Asphalt shingles have been a mainstay in residential and commercial construction since 1903, when Henry M. Reynolds first invented asphalt shingles made with shards of quartz, brick, and slate. However, in recent decades metal roofing has grown to become a fundamental game changer in the industry. We’re asked the question frequently, from both our dealers and our customers – which is better? And which one should I choose for my current project?
As a steel roof manufacturer since the early 1990s, we’re obviously a little biased towards steel. However, it’s good to know the pros and cons of both builds.
Affordability
For most people interested in renovating or building a roof for their property, affordability is one of, if not the, first thing on their minds. Here’s where asphalt shingles have a slight advantage. Because of the base materials being inexpensive, as well as their relatively easy installation (they’re typically nailed into wooden-framed structures, layered from upward to the lowest point), shingles tend to have a lower cost than steel.
If the immediate upfront budget is of your highest priority, you may want to consider asphalt. However, we feel that’s a short-term consideration, because when discussing roofing options, there are two cost factors to consider.
Immediate Cost vs. Long Term Cost
Metal roofing has a very high longevity, much longer than asphalt shingles. Whereas you may find yourself having to repair asphalt roofing every few years, metal roofing can remain durable and aesthetically consistent for decades. A recent study by Forbes estimates most metal roofs have a lifespan of 70 years, whereas asphalt shingles typically have completely deteriorated after 40. Our senior sales advisor, Tyler Broderson, explains it this way to his customers:
There are a range of metal roofing options to consider, such as corrugated metals and interlocking standing seam. All of these, while more complicated to install than asphalt shingles, result in a far stronger end product that can both stand the test of time and weather the elements.
Other Factors Beside Cost
Having to pay more in the long run with shingles isn’t the only detriment to using asphalt as opposed to steel. Steel has a longer lifespan specifically because of its heightened durability, where it can withstand extreme weather like rain, snow, wind, and hail. If you live in an area with frequent weather issues such as those, a steel roof will be the much more secure option for your needs.
Another positive about metal roofing is one that isn’t discussed much – metal roofing can actually save you energy costs! Metal reflects the UV and infrared light from the sun, whereas asphalt absorbs the radiant heat. Because of this, metal roofing panels have recently been Energy Star-rated, and can keep your home up to 30% cooler in the summer months. So, if you’re looking at your energy bill in August and become frustrated by how much it costs to keep your air conditioner going, think metal!
What Comes Out On Top?
If your only priority is saving some bucks right off the hop, then asphalt shingles are a perfectly fine way to adorn a roof. But as you’ve hopefully learned, the overall lifetime benefits of metal roofing far surpass what asphalt can deliver. Couple all this with how many colour, texture, and aesthetic options are available with metal, and we feel confident in saying that the best way to invest in a roof is with steel.
(Especially Forma Steel).
